The Authoritative Voice of India's Liquor IndustryFriday, 20 November 2026
HomeCurrent AffairsOne Nation, Many Excise Laws: Why India Needs a Model Liquor Law
Policy

One Nation, Many Excise Laws: Why India Needs a Model Liquor Law

India's liquor sector faces fragmentation and inefficiency. A unified Model Excise Law, backed by IT integration and fiscal incentives, can harmonise regulation, protect revenues, and ensure safer products.

BW Online Bureau/ BW Legal World
|Sep 17, 2025|7 min read|
One Nation, Many Excise Laws: Why India Needs a Model Liquor Law

India's liquor industry is one of its largest revenue earners and yet among the most administratively inefficient. Contributing between 15–25 per cent of many states' own tax revenues, alcohol for human consumption has been deliberately kept outside GST. This decision has left the sector governed entirely by state excise laws — fragmented, inconsistent, and costly.

Each state runs its own licensing, pricing, and IT systems. A distillery in Punjab exporting beer or any Indian Made Foreign Liquor to Maharashtra must secure separate permits, pay multiple fees, and reconcile across incompatible IT portals. Maximum Retail Price (MRP) fixation is equally fractured; Tamil Nadu dictates MRPs through TASMAC, Delhi approves cost sheets, and Rajasthan issues annual notifications post-tenders. The same product retails at different prices across borders, fuelling arbitrage, smuggling, and illicit liquor trade.

The costs are threefold: businesses face high compliance burdens, states suffer revenue leakages, and consumers face greater risk of unsafe alcohol.

India has already overcome such fragmentation once before. In the 1990s, each state ran its own sales tax regime. A consensus emerged at the Conference of Chief Ministers in 1999, leading to the formation of the Empowered Committee of State Finance Ministers under Dr. Asim Dasgupta. The Committee circulated a Model VAT Bill, culminating in the White Paper on State-Level VAT (January 2005). This White Paper laid down a uniform structure — common definitions, input tax credit, self-assessment, and two standard rates — while preserving states' freedom to fix actual rates.

When India transitioned to VAT, the Centre not only circulated a Model VAT Bill but also underwrote the shift with a three-year compensation package — 100 per cent of revenue losses in 2005–06, 75 per cent in 2006–07, and 50 per cent in 2007–08. Budget provisions of ₹3,000 crore in 2006–07 were earmarked, and when the Central Sales Tax (CST) was reduced from 4 per cent to 2 per cent between 2007–08, the Union compensated states with ₹14,000 crore in 2010–11 and ₹12,000 crore in 2011–12. In parallel, a national IT backbone — TINXSYS — was created to allow inter-state verification of VAT transactions. This combination of a model law, fiscal cushions, and shared technology ensured near-universal adoption of VAT by 2010.

By contrast, the liquor sector today remains outside GST and continues to be regulated entirely by state excise laws. States retain full fiscal control, leading to inconsistent licensing, permit, and pricing systems. While some states such as Uttar Pradesh, Haryana, and Andhra Pradesh have introduced progressive reforms like composite vends or premium retail formats, others retain opaque and archaic frameworks. Industry bodies like ISWAI and CIABC continue to flag discriminatory brand registration fees, cross-border smuggling, and heavy compliance costs. Despite calls for reform, no Model Excise Law has been circulated, no pan-India IT system like TINXSYS exists, and no central fiscal incentive package has been offered to encourage harmonisation.

The Supreme Court's recent nine-judge bench decision in State of Uttar Pradesh v. Lalta Prasad Vaish & Sons (2024) reaffirmed that states hold exclusive legislative power to regulate even industrial alcohol under Entry 8 of the State List. By overruling earlier limits imposed in Synthetics & Chemicals and related cases, the Court has tilted the balance firmly in favour of state autonomy. This opens dialogue for a 'Model Excise Law' circulated by the Centre, voluntarily adopted by states, and backed by subsidies and a shared IT backbone. In effect, harmonisation can only come through cooperation, not compulsion.

The way forward lies in replicating the VAT reform model across three pillars. First, an Empowered Committee on State Excise should draft a Model State Excise Act and Rules, standardising definitions (wholesale, retail, bar licences), permit structures, MRP fixation methodology, and enforcement mechanisms — while states remain free to set their own duty and fee rates. Second, a national excise IT platform — "EXISEX" — on the lines of TINXSYS or GSTN, can enable online issuance and authentication of import/export permits, a pan-India registry of brands and licences, QR/barcode-based track-and-trace to curb spurious liquor, and mutual recognition of digitally signed permits across states. Third, a uniform MRP methodology — ex-distillery price plus notified cost heads plus state-specific duties and fees — would ensure transparency and comparability, even if rates differ.

For businesses, harmonisation reduces compliance duplication and creates predictability in interstate operations. For states, it plugs leakages, lowers enforcement costs, and raises sustainable revenues. For consumers, it ensures safer products through track-and-trace, transparent pricing, and reduced smuggling. In effect, it delivers efficiency without infringing state sovereignty.

Instead of direct fiscal compensation, the Centre can design a package of non-fiscal enablers: targeted subsidies for IT integration, capacity-building support, and simplified approval systems to reduce compliance costs. A dedicated Mission Mode Project for Excise under the National e-Governance Plan could be launched, offering technical assistance and infrastructure grants for computerisation and EXISEX integration. By aligning reforms with ease-of-doing-business goals, states can see clear advantages: faster interstate approvals, reduced smuggling at borders, transparent MRP fixation, and greater investment from premium domestic and international brands.

Liquor excise remains one of India's last unreformed indirect tax frontiers. Each state runs its own patchwork regime, producing inefficiency, leakage, and risk. Yet, the VAT experience shows how consensus, compensation, and common IT rails can deliver harmonisation while preserving fiscal autonomy. The legal foundations exist, the fiscal template is tested, and the administrative technology is off-the-shelf. All that is required is political will. One nation, many excise laws have been the default for decades. It is time to change that.

Source: BW Legal World (https://www.bwlegalworld.com/article/one-nation-many-excise-laws-why-india-needs-a-model-liquor-law-572025)

Tags:Model Excise LawIndiaGSTState ExciseEXISEXHarmonisationPolicy ReformISWAICIABCमॉडेल उत्पादन शुल्क कायदाभारतजीएसटीराज्य उत्पादन शुल्कसुसंगतताधोरण सुधारणामद्य कायदाएकसमान नियमावलीMaharashtra State ExciseState Liquor Lawsमहाराष्ट्र राज्य उत्पादन शुल्कराज्य मद्य कायदे