Maharashtra's 'Made in Maharashtra' Liquor Policy Faces Legal Challenge in Bombay High Court
ISWA — whose members include Pernod Ricard, Diageo and Bacardi — has challenged the Maharashtra Government's policy mandating 25% shelf space for locally manufactured liquor brands, arguing it violates constitutional rights and distorts market competition.
The Maharashtra Government's 'Made in Maharashtra' liquor policy is facing legal opposition after the International Spirits and Wines Association of India (ISWA) challenged it in the Bombay High Court. Introduced on August 7, 2025, the policy requires bars and permit rooms across the state to reserve at least 25% shelf space for locally manufactured liquor brands. It also creates a new category called Maharashtra Made Liquor (MML), which benefits from lower excise duties and price caps. To qualify, liquor manufacturers must be headquartered in Maharashtra, have at least 25% local promoters, and no foreign investment.
The State government has defended the policy as an effort to strengthen local manufacturing, improve revenue generation, and correct market concentration. According to the government, nine licence holders linked to ISWA members accounted for 64% of liquor production in Maharashtra during 2024–25.
Representing ISWA, senior advocates Darius Khambata and Rohan Shah argued that the policy violates Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. They contended that the rules create an arbitrary classification and unfairly compel businesses to stock products regardless of consumer demand.
"This is not about promoting choice; it is about compelling businesses to act against market demand," Mr. Khambata told the court.
ISWA, whose members include global liquor companies such as Pernod Ricard, Diageo, and Bacardi, maintains that the policy could distort competition and limit consumer choice in the market.
The Maharashtra government, represented by Advocate General Milind Sathe and Government Pleader Neha Bhide, argued that the policy has already resulted in higher excise collections. In its affidavit, the State said revenue between July and November 2025 rose to ₹11,299.40 crore from ₹9,665.64 crore during the same period the previous year — an increase of ₹1,633.76 crore, or 16.9%. The government noted that this growth exceeded the earlier 12% rise recorded before the policy came into force.
"This shows positive growth after the introduction of a new policy," the State said in its submission.
A Division Bench comprising Justices Revati Mohite Dere and Sandesh D. Patil has issued notice to the State and directed it to submit its affidavit-in-reply along with the study group report that formed the basis of the policy.
The court also stated that, until the petition is heard, all parties may continue taking preparatory steps under the August 7, 2025 government decision, without claiming any legal advantage from those actions. The matter is scheduled for hearing on December 23, 2025.